That Pine-Tree Air Freshener on Your Mirror? A $115 Ticket in Minnesota. The Dealer's Plate Frame Can Be Another $105.

November 17, 2026 · David J.S. Madgett

Look at your rearview mirror. If there’s a cardboard pine tree hanging from it, a graduation tassel, a rosary, or a pair of fuzzy dice, you’re driving around with a Minnesota traffic violation dangling in front of your face.

I mean that literally. Minnesota’s windshield statute makes it unlawful to drive with “any objects suspended between the driver and the windshield”, and then it lists the six things that are allowed. An air freshener isn’t one of them. Neither is anything else people actually hang there.

The same goes for the dark tint the last owner put on, and for the plate frame the dealer screwed on that covers the state’s name. None of these is a big fine. Every one of them is a petty misdemeanor an officer can spot from the road.

What can legally hang from the rearview mirror in Minnesota?

Six things, and the statute names them:

(a) A person shall not drive or operate any motor vehicle with:

(1) a windshield cracked or discolored to an extent to limit or obstruct proper vision;

(2) any objects suspended between the driver and the windshield, other than:

(i) sun visors;

(ii) rearview mirrors;

(iii) driver feedback and safety monitoring equipment when mounted immediately behind, slightly above, or slightly below the rearview mirror;

(iv) global positioning systems or navigation systems when mounted or located near the bottommost portion of the windshield;

(v) electronic toll collection devices; and

(vi) an identifying device as provided in section 169.58, subdivision 5, when the device is mounted or located near the bottommost portion of the windshield; or

(3) any sign, poster, or other nontransparent material upon the front windshield, sidewings, or side or rear windows of the vehicle, other than a certificate or other paper required to be so displayed by law or authorized by the state director of the Division of Emergency Management or the commissioner of public safety.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.71, subd. 1(a)

Read clause (2) as a list of permission slips. The sun visor and the mirror are there because otherwise the car itself would be illegal. The toll transponder made the cut. So did “driver feedback and safety monitoring equipment”, which I read to cover a dash camera tucked right behind the mirror, and the GPS, but only “near the bottommost portion of the windshield”. A phone mount suctioned to the middle of the glass isn’t near the bottom of anything.

Clause (vi) is the newest-looking item on the list, and it’s for Uber and Lyft. Section 169.58, subdivision 5 lets a “transportation network company vehicle” carry “no more than two removable, interior-mounted, trade dress identifying devices” so riders can find their driver, as long as the light isn’t red, amber, or blue and doesn’t flash. So the glowing rideshare logo at the bottom of the windshield is legal. The pine tree above it isn’t.

What isn’t on the list: the air freshener, the tassel, the rosary, the dice, the parking-ramp hang tag, the baby shoes.

Not even the disability parking certificate, and that’s the strangest one. To get the parking privileges, the certificate has to be “prominently displayed”, and the statute defines that as hanging it “from the rearview mirror attached to the front windshield of the motor vehicle”. Minn. Stat. § 169.345, subd. 1(b). The privileges apply “only while the vehicle is actually parked while transporting a physically disabled person.” § 169.345, subd. 3(b). The windshield statute’s exception for “a certificate or other paper required to be so displayed by law” sits in clause (3), the one about signs on the glass, not in clause (2), the one about things hanging in front of you. So one statute tells you to hang the placard on the mirror when you park, and the other doesn’t list it among the things that can hang there while you drive. Take it down before you pull out.

Law enforcement vehicles are exempt from clauses (2) and (3), and authorized emergency vehicles from clause (2). § 169.71, subd. 1(b)–(c). So the squad car can have a laptop mount and a stack of paperwork on the dash. You can’t have a pine tree.

Yes, even the stick-figure family on your back window

Clause (3) is the one nobody reads. It bars “any sign, poster, or other nontransparent material” on “the front windshield, sidewings, or side or rear windows of the vehicle”. The only exception for you is “a certificate or other paper required to be so displayed by law” or authorized by the state’s emergency-management director or the commissioner of public safety.

Read literally, that reaches the college decal on the back window, the “Baby on Board” sign, and the stick-figure family with the dog. The Legislature probably wasn’t picturing the stick-figure family. The words still reach it, and they don’t ask whether you can see around the sticker.

Clause (1) is the crack. A windshield “cracked or discolored to an extent to limit or obstruct proper vision” is its own violation. Not every rock chip counts. A crack that runs across your line of sight can.

How dark can window tint be in Minnesota?

Here’s the rule:

(3) when any side window or rear window is composed of or treated with any material so as to obstruct or substantially reduce the driver’s clear view through the window or has a light transmittance of less than 50 percent plus or minus three percent in the visible light range or a luminous reflectance of more than 20 percent plus or minus three percent; or

— Minn. Stat. § 169.71, subd. 4(3)

So the side and rear windows have to let through at least 50 percent of visible light, with a three-point tolerance, and they can’t reflect more than 20 percent, with the same tolerance. The windshield gets no percentage at all. You can’t drive with a windshield treated with “any material which has the effect of making the windshield more reflective or in any other way reducing light transmittance through the windshield”. § 169.71, subd. 4(1). Any window with “a highly reflective or mirrored appearance” is out. Subd. 4(2). And any film applied after August 1, 1985 has to carry “an accompanying permanent marking which indicates the percent of transmittance and the percent of reflectance afforded by the material.” Subd. 4(4).

The exceptions are where it gets interesting. Subdivision 4 doesn’t apply to:

  • glass that hasn’t been modified since it left the factory, or factory-original replacements, installed “in conformity with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 205”;
  • tint required for a medical need, with paperwork (more on that below);
  • “the rear windows of a pickup truck”;
  • “the rear windows or the side windows on either side behind the driver’s seat of a van”;
  • “the side and rear windows of a vehicle used to transport human remains by a funeral establishment” licensed under § 149A.50;
  • “the side and rear windows of a limousine”; and
  • “the rear and side windows of a police vehicle.”

§ 169.71, subd. 4a(a).

Notice what’s not on that list: SUVs. People assume the rule for the back half of an SUV is the same as for a van. The statute says “van as defined in section 168.002, subdivision 40”, and that definition is “any vehicle of box-like design with no barrier or separation between the operator’s area and the remainder of the cargo-carrying area, and with a manufacturer’s nominal rated carrying capacity of three-fourths ton or less.” Whether your SUV is “of box-like design” is an argument, and I wouldn’t want to make it from the shoulder. The factory privacy glass on the back half of most SUVs is a different story: glass that “ha[s] not been modified since the original installation” and met Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 205 is outside subdivision 4 entirely. The aftermarket film on top of it is the problem.

Then there’s my favorite sentence in the section. A tint shop that applies illegal film commits a misdemeanor, and so does anyone who sells windows that don’t comply. § 169.71, subd. 5(a)–(b). But subdivision 5 “does not apply to sale or offers for sale of a motor vehicle containing windows or windshields composed of, covered by, or treated with material that fails to comply with the provisions of subdivision 4.” Subd. 5(c). So the used-car lot can sell you a sedan with limo tint on every window, legally. You’re the one who gets the ticket driving it home.

The medical tint exemption changed twice in two years

If you need darker windows for a medical reason, the statute lets you have them, but only with paperwork that says the right things. The driver or a passenger has to have “a prescription or a physician’s or optometrist’s statement of medical need”; it has to say “whether the medical need is a temporary or permanent condition”; it has to state “the minimum percentage that light transmittance may be reduced”; and it has to carry an expiration date “no more than two years after the date the prescription or statement was issued”, unless the doctor indicates the condition is permanent. § 169.71, subd. 4a(a)(2).

Two of those requirements are new. A 2025 law added the temporary-or-permanent statement, made the doctor supply the expiration date, and allowed no expiration for a permanent condition, for prescriptions issued on or after July 1, 2025. 2025 Minn. Laws ch. 5, § 1 (signed April 24, 2025). Then in 2026 the Legislature noticed the exemption said “physician” everywhere and added optometrists, signed May 12, 2026, and made it “effective retroactively from July 1, 2025”. 2026 Minn. Laws ch. 89, § 1. If you’ve got an older note, look at it again.

There’s also a family rule. A driver may rely on a prescription issued to someone who isn’t in the car if it was issued to “the driver’s parent, child, grandparent, grandchild, sibling, or spouse”, or to someone the driver is a personal care attendant for; if it names “the make, model, and license plate of one or two vehicles that will have tinted windows”; and if the driver has it with him. § 169.71, subd. 4a(b). Keep it in the glove box.

Can a license plate frame be illegal in Minnesota?

Yes, if it covers the wrong part of the plate:

All plates must be (1) securely fastened so as to prevent them from swinging, (2) displayed horizontally with the identifying numbers and letters facing outward from the vehicle, and (3) mounted in the upright position. The person driving the motor vehicle shall keep the plate legible and unobstructed and free from grease, dust, or other blurring material so that the lettering is plainly visible at all times. It is unlawful to cover any assigned letters and numbers or the name of the state of origin of a license plate with any material whatever, including any clear or colorless material that affects the plate’s visibility or reflectivity.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.79, subd. 7

“[T]he name of the state of origin”. A dealer frame with the dealership’s name stamped across the top of the plate is fine as long as it stays off the letters, the numbers, and the state’s name. Once it covers the state name, it’s a violation, and so is the smoked plastic cover that’s supposed to beat the cameras. The statute says “any material whatever”, clear or not, if it affects visibility or reflectivity. And “free from grease, dust, or other blurring material” means a plate caked in February road slush is technically a violation too.

You need two plates on most cars. “If the motor vehicle is any kind of motor vehicle other than those provided for in subdivisions 2 to 4, one plate must be displayed on the front and one on the rear of the vehicle.” § 169.79, subd. 6. The exceptions are motorcycles, trailers, semitrailers, vehicles with dealer plates, and collector and pre-1973 cars, among others. Subds. 3–4. And since 2024, “a roadable aircraft is not required to display a license plate.” Subd. 3b; 2024 Minn. Laws ch. 104, art. 1, § 45. So if your car can fly, skip the front bracket.

The tabs have assigned seats, too: month of expiration in the lower left corner, year in the lower right. § 169.79, subd. 8.

The plate is also what every license-plate-reader camera in the state is reading. I wrote about what those cameras record, and how long the government can keep it, at /news/minnesota-license-plate-reader-data-13-824/.

What does each of these cost?

Each is a petty misdemeanor, because chapter 169 makes a violation one unless it says otherwise. Minn. Stat. § 169.89, subd. 1. That means no jury, no jail, and “a fine of not more than $300.” § 169.89, subd. 2.

The Minnesota Judicial Branch’s 2026 statewide payables list, effective January 1, 2026, sets the actual numbers:

  • “Windshield prohibitions”, § 169.71, subd. 1(a)(1)–(3) (the air freshener, the stickers, the crack): $40 fine plus a $75 surcharge, $115.
  • “Restrictions on mirrored/glazed windows”, § 169.71, subd. 4 (the tint): $50 plus $75, $125.
  • “Vehicle registration - license plate violation”, § 169.79 (the frame, the cover, the missing front plate): $30 plus $75, $105.
  • Selling or applying illegal tint, § 169.71, subd. 5(a), a misdemeanor: $300 plus $75, $375.

The list flags the windshield and tint violations for certification to the Department of Public Safety. The plate violation is marked “N”.

The fine isn’t the point, though. A $115 ticket is a nuisance. The stop that comes with it is the whole ballgame.

Has the Legislature done anything about these stops?

People have tried. The closest anyone got is sitting in the bill files.

In the 2023–2024 session, House File 1832 would have created a new chapter 169 section, “VEHICLE EQUIPMENT SECONDARY OFFENSES.” The mirror clause, the window-sign clause, the tint rule, and the plate stickers all went on its list of “mandatory secondary offenses”, and for those, “A peace officer may not stop or detain the operator of a motor vehicle for a mandatory secondary offense and may not issue a citation for a mandatory secondary offense”, unless the officer had already stopped the car for a moving violation unrelated to its equipment, or the car was unoccupied. Commercial vehicles were left out. A second House bill, HF 4922, introduced March 13, 2024, said the same thing in plainer English. Its list of mandatory secondary offenses included “driving with an item dangling from the rearview mirror”.

Neither one passed. HF 4922’s status page shows it was introduced, referred to the transportation committee, and picked up a second author on March 25, 2024. That’s the whole history. The Senate versions, SF 2232 in 2023 and SF 3589 in 2024, show an introduction and a referral to the Judiciary and Public Safety committee. SF 2232 picked up two more authors after that. Neither moved. HF 1832’s page ends differently: it points to the 2024 public safety bill, 2024 Minn. Laws ch. 123, for the parts that made it in. The stop limits aren’t among them. I searched that chapter’s full text for “stop or detain” and “secondary offense” and came up empty.

Two smaller things did make it into chapter 123, signed May 24, 2024.

The first is a working group on tabs. The commissioner of public safety had to convene a Motor Vehicle Registration Compliance Working Group by September 1, 2024, to look at ways to enforce registration “that would replace enforcement through the use of criminal penalties”, judged by criteria that included the “substantial elimination of vehicle registration enforcement through traffic stops performed by peace officers.” Its report was due February 15, 2025, and the group expired June 30, 2025. 2024 Minn. Laws ch. 123, art. 5, § 16. That’s about expired tabs, not the air freshener.

The second is the one I’d frame. You know the line. The officer walks up, leans in, and asks, “Do you know why I pulled you over?” In Minnesota, that’s been against the law since 2024:

A peace officer making a traffic stop for a violation of this chapter or chapter 168 must not ask if the operator can identify the reason for the stop. A peace officer making such a traffic stop must inform the vehicle’s operator of a reason for the stop unless it would be unreasonable to do so under the totality of the circumstances. A peace officer’s failure to comply with this section must not serve as the basis for exclusion of evidence or dismissal of a charge or citation. Section 645.241 does not apply to violations of this section.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.905

Read the last two sentences, though. The officer who asks anyway doesn’t lose the evidence and doesn’t lose the ticket. And § 645.241 is the catch-all that makes breaking a statute with no penalty of its own a petty misdemeanor, so switching it off means the officer doesn’t get a ticket either. The Legislature banned the question and then made sure nothing happens when it gets asked.

Meanwhile the statutes this article is about haven’t moved. The Revisor’s amendment record for § 169.71 shows subdivision 1, the air-freshener clause, last amended in 2019; the only changes since are the 2025 and 2026 medical-tint fixes to subdivision 4a. Section 169.79 was last amended in 2024, to add the flying-car exemption. The Revisor’s table of statutes changed in the 2025 and 2026 sessions shows one new chapter 169 section, and it’s about selling retired squad cars, not about stopping yours.

The ticket is the small part

A stop for an air freshener starts out as a conversation about a petty misdemeanor. What the officer sees, smells, or asks about once he’s at your window is a different area of law, and it’s where these stops end up in court. Whether an officer had probable cause for what came next is usually the whole fight in a false-arrest case, and I walked through how Minnesota and federal courts handle it at /news/minnesota-false-arrest-and-probable-cause/. And the data the stop generates, from the squad’s cameras to the plate reader on the bridge, doesn’t stay at the scene. I covered what your own car reports on you at /news/your-car-is-reporting-on-you-driving-data-minnesota/.

Take the pine tree down. Put it in a cupholder. It smells the same from there.

Madgett Law, LLC

Madgett Law, LLC brings civil rights claims in Minnesota state and federal court, including false arrest and malicious prosecution claims, where probable cause is usually the whole fight. If a traffic stop over something on your windshield or your plate turned into an arrest or worse, read about our civil rights practice, then send us a message.

Sources: Minn. Stat. § 169.71 (2026), subd. 1(a)(1)–(3) (windshield cracks; suspended objects and six exceptions; signs and nontransparent material), subd. 1(b)–(c) (law enforcement and emergency vehicles), subd. 4(1)–(4) (glazing; 50 percent light transmittance and 20 percent luminous reflectance, each plus or minus three percent; marking for material applied after Aug. 1, 1985), subd. 4a(a)–(b) (exceptions; medical prescription or statement; relatives), subd. 5(a)–(c) (sale and application; misdemeanor; sale of a motor vehicle excepted); 2025 Minn. Laws ch. 5, § 1 (S.F. 1075; signed Apr. 24, 2025; effective July 1, 2025); 2026 Minn. Laws ch. 89, § 1 (S.F. 3637; signed May 12, 2026; effective retroactively from July 1, 2025). Minn. Stat. § 169.79 (2026), subds. 3–4 (single-plate vehicles; collector vehicles), subd. 3b (roadable aircraft), subd. 6 (front and rear plates), subd. 7 (plate fastened, legible, unobstructed; no covering of letters, numbers or state name), subd. 8 (registration stickers). Minn. Stat. § 169.89, subd. 1 (petty misdemeanor), subd. 2 (fine of not more than $300). Minnesota Judicial Branch, 2026 State Payables List, Traffic/Criminal (effective Jan. 1, 2026), entries for § 169.71, subds. 1(a)(1)–(3), 4, 5(a), and § 169.79. Minn. Stat. § 169.58, subd. 5 (transportation network company identifying devices). Minn. Stat. § 169.345, subd. 1(b) (certificate displayed by hanging from the rearview mirror), subd. 3(b) (privileges only while parked). Minn. Stat. § 168.002, subd. 40 (van). 2024 Minn. Laws ch. 104, art. 1, § 45 (adding § 169.79, subd. 3b). Minn. Stat. § 169.905 (traffic stop; questioning limited); 2024 Minn. Laws ch. 123, art. 3, § 1 (enacting § 169.905), art. 5, § 16 (Motor Vehicle Registration Compliance Working Group) (H.F. 5216; signed May 24, 2024). Minn. Stat. § 645.241 (prohibited act with no penalty is a petty misdemeanor). H.F. 1832, 93rd Leg. (2023–2024), as introduced, and its status page; S.F. 2232, 93rd Leg. (2023) (status); H.F. 4922, 93rd Leg. (2024), as introduced, and its status page; S.F. 3589, 93rd Leg. (2024) (status). Office of the Revisor of Statutes, Table 2, Minnesota Statutes affected by the 2025 and 2026 sessions (chapter 169); amendment history for § 169.71 and § 169.79. Minn. Stat. § 169.981 (sale or transfer of law enforcement vehicle). This article is general information about Minnesota law. It is not legal advice, it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no particular outcome is promised or implied.

Get new guides by email

Plain-English guides to Minnesota law, sent when a new one is written. No schedule, nothing for sale.

Used only to send these guides. Unsubscribe from any email. This is attorney advertising — subscribing does not create an attorney–client relationship.

← All news & articles