Listening Through Both AirPods While You Drive? That's a $115 Ticket in Minnesota, Under a 1974 Law That Still Says "Tape Decks".

November 19, 2026 · David J.S. Madgett

Next time you’re crawling up 35W, count the white earbuds. Plenty of drivers have both in. In Minnesota, if those earbuds are playing something and the driver doesn’t need them as a hearing aid, he’s breaking a law from 1974. The law is so old it still names the tape deck.

Here’s the sentence:

(a) No person, while operating a motor vehicle, shall wear headphones or earphones that are used in both ears simultaneously for purposes of receiving or listening to broadcasts or reproductions from radios, tape decks, or other sound-producing or transmitting devices.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.471, subd. 2(a)

Both ears, listening to something. That’s the trigger. One earbud is legal. Two is a ticket.

How old is Minnesota’s headphone law?

Fifty-two years old. The Legislature added the headphone ban in 1974: Chapter 460, House File 242, approved April 11, 1974. That’s fifty-two years before this article’s November 19, 2026 byline. The session law’s title says it was “prohibiting the use of certain listening devices while operating a motor vehicle”, and the operative sentence then read almost word for word the way it reads now, down to the “tapedecks”, which the Legislature spelled as one word.

The 1974 version had exactly one exception: “This section shall not prohibit the use, however, of hearing aid devices by persons in need thereof.” The firefighter and ambulance exceptions came later.

Every amendment since has left the tape deck in place. The core sentence that was written for a car stereo now gets enforced against Bluetooth earbuds. That’s either admirable drafting or nobody’s read it in a while.

Can I drive with one AirPod in?

Yes, as far as § 169.471 goes. The ban is on earphones “used in both ears simultaneously”. One ear is outside it, whatever you’re listening to.

Then the hands-free law gets a vote, and it’s more relaxed about your podcast than you’d think. Minnesota’s wireless-device statute bars a driver from using a phone to “access” stored “audio content”, but it carves out listening “to audio-based content in a manner that does not require the driver to scroll or type while the vehicle is in motion or a part of traffic, provided that the person does not hold the device with one or both hands”. Minn. Stat. § 169.475, subds. 2(a)(2)(iii), 3(a)(3). A phone call works the same way: it’s allowed “solely in a voice-activated or hands-free mode”, as long as you don’t hold the phone. § 169.475, subd. 3(a)(1). I went through the rest of that statute, and what it does in a crash case, at /news/minnesota-hands-free-law-crash-case-169-475/.

So the two statutes stack. The hands-free law asks what your hands are doing. The headphone law asks how many ears are plugged. Start the playlist before you put it in drive, keep the phone in the cupholder, and run it through the car speakers or one earbud, and you’ve satisfied both. Put the second earbud in and you’ve broken the older one, even though the newer one is perfectly happy.

What about a phone call with both earbuds?

Here the text doesn’t hand you a clean answer, so here’s how I read it.

The ban reaches “receiving or listening to broadcasts or reproductions from radios, tape decks, or other sound-producing or transmitting devices.” A phone is a transmitting device if anything is. And look at the exceptions the Legislature thought it needed:

(b) Paragraph (a) does not prohibit:

(1) the use of a hearing aid device by a person who needs the device;

(2) the use of a communication headset by a firefighter while operating a fire department emergency vehicle in response to an emergency; or

(3) the use of a communication headset by an emergency medical services person while operating an ambulance subject to section 144E.101.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.471, subd. 2(b)

If a two-way conversation through a headset weren’t covered by paragraph (a), the firefighter and the ambulance driver wouldn’t need an exception. They got one. You didn’t. A trucker’s one-ear Bluetooth headset is fine under this statute because it’s one ear. A noise-canceling pair on both ears for a conference call, I read as inside the ban.

The exceptions are narrow, too. A firefighter gets it only “while operating a fire department emergency vehicle in response to an emergency”. Driving the engine back to the station with both ears covered isn’t on the list.

My AirPods are a hearing aid now. Does that count?

Here’s the corner of the statute nobody saw coming.

On September 12, 2024, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration authorized the first over-the-counter hearing aid software, Apple’s Hearing Aid Feature, which “enables compatible versions of the AirPods Pro to serve as an OTC hearing aid, intended to amplify sounds for individuals 18 years or older with perceived mild to moderate hearing impairment.” So the same pair of earbuds can now be a hearing aid in the FDA’s eyes and a pair of headphones in everybody else’s.

The Minnesota exception covers “the use of a hearing aid device by a person who needs the device”. Two conditions: it has to be a hearing aid device, and you have to need it. A driver with diagnosed mild hearing loss, running the authorized feature, has a real argument that both conditions are met. A driver with normal hearing who turned the feature on to get out of a ticket doesn’t meet the second one.

What the statute doesn’t answer is the hard case: the driver who needs the hearing aid and is also streaming a podcast through it. The exception says paragraph (a) “does not prohibit” the use of the device. It doesn’t say what you’re allowed to pipe through it. The Legislature that wrote the first hearing-aid exception in 1974 was picturing a beige hearing aid, not an earbud with a music library, and I wouldn’t want to be the test case.

Does the headphone law apply on a bike or a motorcycle?

The sentence applies to a person “operating a motor vehicle”. Chapter 169’s definitions decide who that is.

A bicycle isn’t one. “Motor vehicle” means “every vehicle which is self-propelled”, and the definition says outright that it “does not include an electric-assisted bicycle, an electric personal assistive mobility device, or a vehicle moved solely by human power.” Minn. Stat. § 169.011, subd. 42. The bicycle statute gives a rider “all of the rights and duties applicable to the driver of any other vehicle by this chapter”, § 169.222, subd. 1(a), but the headphone duty is written for motor vehicles specifically, and the bicycle section has no headphone rule of its own. I read the statute as not reaching the cyclist with both earbuds in, and that goes for the e-bike too. That’s a reading of the text, not a recommendation. A cyclist who can’t hear the truck behind him has a different problem than a ticket, and I covered the injury side of bike crashes at /news/minnesota-bicycle-pedestrian-crash-claims/.

A motorcycle is one. The definition starts “‘Motorcycle’ means every motor vehicle having a seat or saddle for the use of the rider and designed to travel on not more than three wheels”. § 169.011, subd. 44. The motorcycle section, § 169.974, has its own equipment and helmet rules and no headphone exception. So earbuds in both ears under the helmet are squarely inside the ban.

Speakers built into the helmet are the open question. The statute says “headphones or earphones” and doesn’t define either. A pair of speakers sitting against both ears inside a helmet looks a lot like headphones to me, and the statute gives a rider nothing to point to on the other side.

How much is the ticket?

Not much. Chapter 169 makes a violation a petty misdemeanor unless the section says otherwise, § 169.89, subd. 1, and § 169.471 doesn’t say otherwise. A petty misdemeanor means a judge instead of a jury, no jail, and “a fine of not more than $300.” § 169.89, subd. 2.

The real number comes from the Minnesota Judicial Branch’s 2026 statewide payables list, effective January 1, 2026. For “Unlawful to wear headphones while operating motor vehicle”, it lists a $40 fine and a $75 surcharge: $115. The list flags it for certification to the Department of Public Safety. The television-screen ban in subdivision 1 carries the same $115.

For comparison, the same list prices a second hands-free violation at a $275 fine, $350 with the surcharge. So the second time you’re caught with the phone in your hand costs $350. Two earbuds cost $115 every time.

Two things can make it worse. A chapter 169 violation committed “in a manner or under circumstances so as to endanger or be likely to endanger any person or property” is a misdemeanor, not a petty misdemeanor. § 169.89, subd. 1(1). And so is a petty misdemeanor “when preceded by two or more petty misdemeanor convictions within the immediate preceding 12-month period”. § 169.89, subd. 1(2). (Parking an unattended vehicle is excluded from that bump.) If you already have two petty misdemeanor convictions in the twelve months before you’re caught with both earbuds in, you’re looking at a misdemeanor. And if the officer thinks you endangered someone, the $115 price tag goes away. The payables list says a citation is presumed payable “unless the endangerment box is checked.”

The dashboard-TV ban from 1949

The same section opens with a ban that’s even older. Chapter 78, House File 569, approved February 28, 1949, said “No television screen shall be installed or used in any motor vehicle at any point forward of the back of the driver’s seat, or which is visible to the driver while operating the motor vehicle.” It was a misdemeanor. I’d love to know what car prompted it.

The current version reads like a museum label with a software update:

No television screen shall be installed or used in any motor vehicle where images from the screen are visible to the driver while operating the motor vehicle except:

(1) video screens installed in law enforcement vehicles;

(2) closed-circuit video systems used exclusively to aid the driver’s visibility to the front, rear, or sides of the vehicle; and

(3) video screens installed as part of a vehicle control system or used in intelligent vehicle highway applications.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.471, subd. 1

Clause (2) is your backup camera. I read clause (3) to cover the factory touchscreen in the middle of the dash. The minivan’s flip-down screen for the kids is fine as long as the driver can’t see it. A phone in a dash mount playing a movie is a problem twice over, because the hands-free law separately bars a driver from accessing stored “video content”. § 169.475, subd. 2(a)(2)(iii).

What do the earbuds do to a crash case?

This is the part that matters to a law firm, and it’s where people overestimate the ticket.

Say Kyle, a made-up driver with both earbuds in and a true-crime podcast going, misses the ambulance siren, drifts through a light that just turned red, and hits you. He broke § 169.471. In your injury case, that helps you. It doesn’t win it for you. The rule dates to 1939, when the Legislature added it to the 1937 traffic code:

(b) In all civil actions, a violation of any of the provisions of this chapter, by either or any of the parties to such action or actions shall not be negligence per se but shall be prima facie evidence of negligence only.

— Minn. Stat. § 169.96(b)

Prima facie evidence means the earbuds put negligence on the table, and then Kyle gets to explain. And if he was convicted of the ticket, you can’t show the jury that either. “No record of the conviction of any person for any violation of this chapter shall be admissible as evidence in any court in any civil action.” § 169.94, subd. 1. You prove the earbuds the long way: the officer who saw them, the witness, Kyle’s own words at the scene, whatever his phone recorded.

Then there’s causation. Minnesota’s comparative fault statute says “[l]egal requirements of causal relation apply both to fault as the basis for liability and to contributory fault.” Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 1a. Two earbuds matter when the crash is one a driver would have heard coming: a siren, a horn, a train. They matter a lot less when he rear-ended you at a red light in broad daylight and the podcast had nothing to do with it.

And “either or any of the parties” cuts both ways. If you were the one with both earbuds in when Kyle hit you, expect his lawyer to say so. Your fault doesn’t bar recovery “if the contributory fault was not greater than the fault of the person against whom recovery is sought”, but your damages are “diminished in proportion to the amount of fault attributable to the person recovering.” § 604.01, subd. 1. I walked through how those percentages play out at /news/minnesota-comparative-fault-collateral-source/.

None of that touches the first layer of coverage. Under the No-Fault Act, “every person suffering loss from injury arising out of maintenance or use of a motor vehicle” has “a right to basic economic loss benefits” when the accident happens in Minnesota. Minn. Stat. § 65B.46, subd. 1. Nobody has to prove who was wearing what. I explained who pays those benefits, and in what order, at /news/minnesota-no-fault-auto-basics/.

Take one out. The statute only counts to two.

Madgett Law, LLC

Madgett Law, LLC represents people hurt in Minnesota car, truck, pedestrian, and bicycle crashes, from the insurance claims through the case against the driver who caused it. In a distracted-driving case, what matters early is pinning down what the other driver was doing in the seconds before the crash, before the phone gets traded in and the witnesses forget. Read about our personal injury practice, then send us a message.

Sources: Minn. Stat. § 169.471 (2026), subd. 1 (television screens visible to the driver; three exceptions), subd. 2(a) (headphones or earphones in both ears), subd. 2(b)(1)–(3) (hearing aid; firefighter and EMS communication headsets); 1974 Minn. Laws ch. 460, § 1 (H.F. 242; approved Apr. 11, 1974) (headphone ban; hearing-aid exception); 1949 Minn. Laws ch. 78, §§ 1–2 (H.F. 569; approved Feb. 28, 1949) (television screen ban; misdemeanor). Minn. Stat. § 169.475, subd. 2(a)(2)(iii) (stored audio and video content), subd. 3(a)(1) (voice-activated or hands-free calls), subd. 3(a)(3) (audio-based content without scrolling or typing). Minn. Stat. § 169.011, subd. 42 (motor vehicle; exclusions), subd. 44 (motorcycle). Minn. Stat. § 169.222, subd. 1(a) (bicycle rider’s rights and duties). Minn. Stat. § 169.974 (motorcycles). Minn. Stat. § 169.89, subd. 1(1)–(2) (petty misdemeanor; misdemeanor for endangerment or after two petty misdemeanor convictions within 12 months), subd. 2 (no jury; no imprisonment; fine of not more than $300). Minn. Stat. § 169.94, subd. 1 (record of conviction not admissible in a civil action). Minn. Stat. § 169.96(b) (prima facie evidence of negligence only). 1939 Minn. Laws ch. 430, § 30 (adding paragraph (b)). Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 1 (comparative fault), subd. 1a (causal relation). Minn. Stat. § 65B.46, subd. 1 (right to basic economic loss benefits). Minnesota Judicial Branch, 2026 State Payables List, Traffic/Criminal (effective Jan. 1, 2026), entries for § 169.471, subd. 1 and subd. 2(a) and § 169.475, subd. 2(b). U.S. Food and Drug Administration, “FDA Authorizes First Over-the-Counter Hearing Aid Software” (Sept. 12, 2024). This article is general information about Minnesota law. It is not legal advice, it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no particular outcome is promised or implied.

Get new guides by email

Plain-English guides to Minnesota law, sent when a new one is written. No schedule, nothing for sale.

Used only to send these guides. Unsubscribe from any email. This is attorney advertising — subscribing does not create an attorney–client relationship.

← All news & articles