Bounce a $25 check at a Minnesota drugstore and you can get a letter demanding the $25, a service charge, a $100 civil penalty, and interest, with a line at the bottom saying the matter may go to the county attorney. Over a $25 check.
Most of that letter is legal, county-attorney line included, which surprises people. The part that usually isn’t legal is the one that looks most official: the flat $100. Minnesota’s statute doesn’t hand a store $100. It gives a court the power to award up to $100, and the Eighth Circuit has twice held a collector liable for pretending otherwise. In one of those cases, when a state judge finally set the number, it was $40 a check.
What can a store charge me for a bounced check in Minnesota?
On the spot, $30. Minn. Stat. § 604.113, subd. 2(a), says a service charge “not to exceed $30, may be imposed immediately on any dishonored check by the payee or holder of the check, regardless of mailing a notice of dishonor, if notice of the service charge was conspicuously displayed on the premises when the check was issued.”
That condition matters. No sign at the register when you wrote the check, no statutory service charge. And the sign has a second job: it “must also include a provision notifying the issuer of the check that civil penalties may be imposed for nonpayment.” Only one service charge per check. § 604.113, subd. 2(a).
The $30 has been a plain cap, with no showing of costs, since August 1, 2001. Before that, the statute allowed “up to $20, or actual costs of collection not to exceed $30,” with a separate $25 figure when a law enforcement agency collected. The 2001 act struck the $20, the actual-costs language, and the $25, and it applies to checks issued on or after August 1, 2001. 2001 Minn. Laws ch. 204, §§ 1, 3. A quarter century later, it’s still thirty bucks. Inflation hasn’t touched it.
Two other limits sit in the same subdivision. A store can’t use a sight draft to collect the civil penalties “without prior consent of the issuer.” § 604.113, subd. 2(d). And the statute doesn’t nullify returned-check charges that stay within its limits, or terms for those charges that the parties agreed to in “an express contract.” § 604.113, subd. 2(c). If a lender advanced you cash against a personal check (the payday-loan setup), the lender can add the $30 return-check charge, but the civil penalties “may not be demanded or assessed against the borrower.” Minn. Stat. § 47.60, subd. 2(e).
The $100 is something a court decides
Here’s the sentence that does the damage, from subdivision 2(b)(1). If the check isn’t paid within 30 days after the payee mails notice of dishonor, the person who wrote it is liable for:
the amount of the check, the service charge as provided in paragraph (a), plus a civil penalty of up to $100 or the value of the check, whichever is greater. In determining the amount of the penalty, the court shall consider the amount of the check and the reason for nonpayment. The civil penalty may not be imposed until 30 days following the mailing of the notice of dishonor.
— Minn. Stat. § 604.113, subd. 2(b)(1) (emphasis added)
Read the cap the way a court has to. On a $40 check the ceiling is $100. On a $400 check the ceiling is $400. Either way it’s a ceiling, and a judge sets the actual number by looking at how big the check was and why it wasn’t paid. The bolded sentence came in with the 2001 rewrite. 2001 Minn. Laws ch. 204, § 1.
The rest of the list: interest “at the rate payable on judgments pursuant to section 549.09” on the face amount from the date of dishonor, and attorney fees, but only “if the aggregate amount of dishonored checks issued by the issuer to all payees within a six-month period is over $1,250.” § 604.113, subd. 2(b)(2)–(3). One bounced $60 check doesn’t put your lawyer’s bill on the table. (How the § 549.09 rate works is at /news/minnesota-prejudgment-interest-on-verdicts/.)
The Eighth Circuit read the older version of this cap in 2000. Three people had written checks for $25.00, $24.40, and $11.38 to a drugstore and a liquor store. A collection company sent letters on a lawyer’s letterhead saying Minnesota law provided a “civil penalty in the amount of $100.00.” The court called the difference between “$100” and “up to $100” “a subtle one,” and then held it was real:
It is not certain that a Minnesota court would impose the entire $100 penalty in any given situation. In fact, it is probably unlikely in the case of a $10 bad check.
— Duffy v. Landberg, 215 F.3d 871, 874 (8th Cir. 2000)
Demanding the full $100 as a fixed sum, payable without ever going to court, was “a misleading representation of Minnesota law” and violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Id. I wrote about the same case’s interest holding, and why an overcharge of $1.29 still counts, at /news/minnesota-debt-collector-pay-to-pay-fees/.
Less than eight months later the same court went further. In Picht v. Jon R. Hawks, Ltd., 236 F.3d 446 (8th Cir. 2001), a couple had four checks totaling $50.25 bounce because a paycheck they’d deposited bounced first. The stores sent the checks to a collection company, and the law firm it hired sued the couple, then garnished their bank account before any judgment was entered, claiming $400 in civil penalties, $100 a check. Without a court order, Minnesota allows that kind of prejudgment garnishment only where the court administrator could enter a default judgment on a claim “upon a contract for the payment of money only”. The court held the check penalty doesn’t qualify, because “section 332.50 requires the exercise of judicial discretion in establishing the civil penalty for a dishonored check.” 236 F.3d at 451. The garnishment was a threat “to take any action that cannot legally be taken”, and the firm was liable under the FDCPA. Id.
And the number the state court eventually picked? “[A] civil penalty of $40 per dishonored check.” Id. at 448 n.2.
Section 332.50 is today’s § 604.113; the Revisor renumbered it in 2001. Both cases read older wording, and one piece of that wording is gone. The version Duffy applied also required the payee to settle for the check, court costs, and the service charge if the writer paid before a hearing. The Legislature struck that settle-before-hearing paragraph in 1997. 1997 Minn. Laws ch. 157, § 66. The “up to” survived every rewrite, though, and the 2001 sentence telling the court what to weigh makes the discretion point stronger. That’s my reading of the current text. The prejudgment-garnishment statute Picht applied still turns on Rule 55.01(a), with the same Notice of Intent to Garnish and a wait that is now 45 days. Minn. Stat. § 571.71(2).
Can the letter really threaten to call the county attorney?
From the store, yes. The criminal statute says so in plain words. The notice of dishonor “may state that unless the check is paid in full within five business days after mailing of the notice of nonpayment or dishonor, the payee or holder of the check will or may refer the matter to proper authorities for prosecution under this section.” Minn. Stat. § 609.535, subd. 3.
That’s the Legislature writing the threat into the form letter. But the crime itself is narrower than the threat makes it sound. Issuing a dishonored check is a crime when, “at the time of issuance, the issuer intends shall not be paid”. § 609.535, subd. 2. The statute lists what’s enough evidence of that intent: no account at all, or not enough funds plus failing to pay within five business days after the notice was mailed. § 609.535, subd. 3(1)–(3). The penalties scale with the amount: up to 90 days for $250 or less, up to 364 days for more than $250 up to $500, up to five years for more than $500, with checks inside six months aggregated. § 609.535, subd. 2a.
The criminal statute “does not apply to a postdated check or to a check given for a past consideration, except a payroll check or a check issued to a fund for employee benefits.” § 609.535, subd. 5. So a check you wrote to pay down an old balance, or one you dated next Friday, isn’t the crime the letter is waving at.
From a third-party collector, the rules tighten. The Eighth Circuit held in 1998 that a bounced check written for household goods creates a “debt” under the FDCPA, so collectors working these checks are covered. Duffy v. Landberg, 133 F.3d 1120, 1123–24 (8th Cir. 1998). The court also said the obvious thing about the crime: “Dishonored checks are only criminal or tortious when the drawer knows or intends the check to be dishonored at the time it is written.” Id. at 1124. A collector may not falsely represent or imply “that the consumer committed any crime”, and may not threaten “to take any action that cannot legally be taken or that is not intended to be taken.” 15 U.S.C. § 1692e(5), (7). A collector also can’t solicit a postdated check “for the purpose of threatening or instituting criminal prosecution.” 15 U.S.C. § 1692f(3).
So a collector that threatens prosecution over a check that bounced because your paycheck did has some explaining to do. What the FDCPA covers, and the Minnesota collection-agency rules stacked on top of it, is at /news/minnesota-debt-collection-practices/.
What if the letter never reached me?
The notice has to cite § 604.113 and § 609.535, describe the penalties, and go by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by regular mail backed by an affidavit of service, “to the address printed or written on the check.” § 604.113, subd. 3. Writing a check with an address on it is “a representation by the drawer that the address is the correct address”, and failing to receive mail there “is not a defense to liability under this section, if the drawer has had actual notice for 30 days that the check has been dishonored.” Id.
The Court of Appeals has read that as a knowledge rule. It calls the 30 days “a type of grace period so that liability does not attach until after 30 days from the time the drawer had knowledge of the dishonor.” Metro Milwaukee Auto Auction v. Coulson, 604 N.W.2d 111, 116 (Minn. Ct. App. 2000), review denied (Minn. Mar. 14, 2000). Knowledge can come from the mailed notice or from actually knowing the check bounced.
In 2008 it applied the same rule to a hard set of facts. A buyer paid a gold dealer with a check for $232,195.50, went into the hospital two days later, fell into a coma, and died. The dealer’s notice went to his house, where his nephew got it. The court held the statute “requires that the issuer of a dishonored check receive actual notice of the dishonored check before civil penalties may attach”, and that impossibility is a valid defense, because nobody could get to his account inside the 30 days. Metro Gold, Inc. v. Coin, 757 N.W.2d 924, 929 (Minn. Ct. App. 2008). The estate paid the check. The penalties, interest, and fees were off. Subdivision 5 is what opened that door: “Any defense otherwise available to the issuer also applies to liability under this section.” § 604.113, subd. 5.
I stopped payment on purpose. Am I on the hook?
Not for the penalties in this statute, if you had a good reason. Whether you still owe the underlying money is a contract fight. “Dishonor” here borrows the UCC definition “but does not include dishonor due to a stop payment order requested by an issuer who has a good faith defense to payment on the check.” § 604.113, subd. 1(d). The contractor who didn’t show up, the car that died in the lot: that’s what a stop-payment order is for.
There’s a catch written into the very next sentence. A stop-payment order still counts as a dishonor “if the account did not have sufficient funds for payment of the check at the time of presentment, except for stop payment orders on a check found to be stolen.” Id. Stopping payment on a check you couldn’t have covered anyway doesn’t get you out.
One more definitional point. The statute starts with “Whoever issues any check” and never defines “issuer”. Minnesota’s UCC does: an issuer is “a maker or drawer of an instrument.” Minn. Stat. § 336.3-105(c). I read that to leave out someone who only endorsed the check over to the store. I couldn’t find a Minnesota appellate decision on the endorser question either way.
A prosecutor’s diversion program can wipe out the penalty
A county or city attorney “may establish a pretrial diversion program” for people charged with, or facing probable cause for, a § 609.535 violation, and the program “may be conducted by the prosecutor or by a private entity under contract with the prosecutor.” Minn. Stat. § 628.69, subds. 1–2. Yes, the bad-check program can be outsourced.
At a minimum it requires a money-management class “at their own expense”, full restitution, and the $30 service charge under § 604.113, subd. 2(a). § 628.69, subd. 4(a). The prosecutor can waive the class fee for economic hardship. Id., subd. 4(b). Finish it, and the civil penalty is gone: the payee “may not recover the penalties described in section 604.113, subdivision 2, paragraph (b)” for that offense. § 628.69, subd. 5; see § 604.113, subd. 2(e). Getting in isn’t automatic. The prosecutor weighs six factors, including your record and “the wishes of the victim regarding placement in the program.” § 628.69, subd. 3.
Where does a bounced-check case get decided?
Usually conciliation court. Minnesota gives bounced checks their own venue rule. A payee who lives in the county can sue there to recover a check issued there, “even though the defendant or defendants are not residents of the county,” if the § 609.535 notice was sent and it told the drawer that a conciliation action could be brought in that county. Minn. Stat. § 491A.01, subd. 10. That rule “does not apply to a check that has been dishonored by stop payment order.” Id. The general limit is $20,000, or $4,000 for a claim involving a consumer credit transaction. § 491A.01, subd. 3a(a). The rest of how conciliation court runs is at /news/minnesota-conciliation-court-491a/.
If you’re served and don’t answer, the case moves toward a default. Picht is the reason a check-penalty claim isn’t supposed to become a clerk’s default for a fixed sum. What a default judgment does, and how a court sets the amount when the claim isn’t for a sum certain, is at /news/minnesota-default-judgment-rule-55/.
If you’re the merchant
The statute is friendlier to you than the collection letters make it look, as long as you do it in order:
- Post the sign before the check is written, and make it mention civil penalties. That’s the price of the $30 and the predicate for the notice language in subdivision 2(b)(1).
- Mail the notice to the address on the check, by certified mail or by regular mail with an affidavit of service, cite both § 604.113 and § 609.535, describe the penalties, and keep the affidavit. § 604.113, subd. 3. If you want the home-county conciliation venue, say so in the notice. § 491A.01, subd. 10.
- Record the writer’s name, address, phone number, and driver’s license or state ID number on the check, compare the ID, and initial it. Do that and the check is prima facie evidence of who wrote it. § 604.113, subd. 4.
- If you send a written demand for the civil liability, describe the penalty the way the statute does: up to $100 or the value of the check, for a court to set. Duffy was a collector case under the FDCPA, but a letter that states the law the way the Legislature wrote it is a lot harder to pick a fight with.
Madgett Law, LLC
Madgett Law, LLC represents Minnesota consumers in debt collection disputes, in state and federal court, including FDCPA claims against collectors who demand more than the law allows. We also represent businesses whose customers stop paying. More on that work is on our general litigation page. If you’ve got a bounced-check letter with a flat $100 penalty on it, or you’re a business trying to collect on a stack of returned checks the right way, send us a message.
Sources: Minn. Stat. § 604.113, subd. 1(d) (dishonor; good-faith stop payment; insufficient-funds exception), subd. 2(a) ($30 service charge; posted notice; one per check), subd. 2(b)(1)–(3) (civil penalty up to $100 or the value of the check; factors the court shall consider; 30-day wait; written demand; § 549.09 interest; attorney fees over $1,250 in six months), subd. 2(c) (express-contract charges), subd. 2(d) (sight drafts), subd. 2(e) (pretrial diversion), subd. 3 (notice of dishonor; address on the check; actual notice), subd. 4 (proof of identity), subd. 5 (defenses). 2001 Minn. Laws ch. 204, §§ 1, 3 (rewriting § 332.50, including the $30 service charge and the court-shall-consider sentence; effective August 1, 2001, for checks issued on or after that date). 1997 Minn. Laws ch. 157, § 66 (striking the former settle-before-hearing paragraph of § 332.50, subd. 2). 2004 Minn. Laws ch. 174, § 3 (law-enforcement retention of the service charge). Minn. Stat. § 645.02 (default effective date). Revisor’s version list for § 332.50 (renumbered § 604.113). Minn. Stat. § 609.535, subd. 2 (intent at issuance), subd. 2a (penalties; aggregation), subd. 3 (proof of intent; notice; prosecution-referral statement), subd. 5 (postdated checks; past consideration). Minn. Stat. § 628.69, subds. 1–5 (pretrial diversion). Minn. Stat. § 47.60, subd. 2(e) (no civil penalties against a consumer small-loan borrower). Minn. Stat. § 336.3-105(c) (issuer). Minn. Stat. § 491A.01, subd. 3a(a) (conciliation court limits), subd. 10 (dishonored-check venue). Minn. Stat. § 571.71(2) (garnishment where a Rule 55.01(a) default could have been entered). Minn. R. Civ. P. 55.01(a). 15 U.S.C. § 1692e(5), (7); § 1692f(3) (govinfo, United States Code 2024 edition). Duffy v. Landberg, 133 F.3d 1120, 1123–24 (8th Cir. 1998); Duffy v. Landberg, 215 F.3d 871, 873–74 (8th Cir. 2000); Picht v. Jon R. Hawks, Ltd., 236 F.3d 446, 448 & n.2, 449–51 (8th Cir. 2001); Metro Milwaukee Auto Auction v. Coulson, 604 N.W.2d 111, 116 (Minn. Ct. App. 2000), review denied (Minn. Mar. 14, 2000); Metro Gold, Inc. v. Coin, 757 N.W.2d 924, 926–29 (Minn. Ct. App. 2008). This article is general legal information about Minnesota law. It is not legal advice, it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no particular outcome is promised or implied.