It snowed overnight. You didn’t get to the sidewalk before work, and the neighbor’s kid went down on it walking to the bus. Most people assume that’s their lawsuit to lose.
Usually it isn’t. In Minnesota the public sidewalk in front of your house is the city’s to keep safe, and the Minnesota Supreme Court has said since 1885 that a city can’t hand that duty to you by ordinance. The shoveling ordinance is real. Break it and the city sends you a bill. What it doesn’t do, on more than a century of case law, is make you answer to the pedestrian.
What can make you answer is ice you made. A downspout that empties across the walk, say, or a roof that dumps its load on whoever happens to be underneath. That’s where homeowners actually get sued, and almost nobody looks up at the gutters when they think about winter liability.
Whose job is the sidewalk in front of your house?
The city’s. That’s been settled Minnesota law for a very long time, and the reasoning is older than most of the houses it applies to.
In 1885, Stillwater’s city charter made lot owners maintain the sidewalks in front of their lots and then went a step further: owners “shall be liable for all damages, to whomsoever resulting,” from failing to keep the walk “in good repair, and in safe, passable condition”. A man hurt on a defective sidewalk sued the city and the owner of the lot next to it. The Minnesota Supreme Court let the case go forward against the city and threw it out against the owner. A sidewalk duty imposed on lot owners, the court said, is “in the nature of a tax,” and it is “owing only to the city”. Noonan v. City of Stillwater, 33 Minn. 198, 199, 205 (1885). Justice Mitchell, concurring, put it the way I’d put it: anything more would mean “compelling every man who owns a lot in a city to turn himself into a street supervisor.” Id. at 206–07 (Mitchell, J., concurring).
Fifty years later the court applied that to snow. In Abar v. Ramsey Motor Service, Inc., a woman fell on ridged ice where a driveway crossed a Minneapolis sidewalk in January 1934. Her lawyer tried, at the start of trial, to plead two city ordinances requiring owners or occupants of abutting property within the fire limits to keep their sidewalks free of ice and snow. The trial court said no, and the Supreme Court said it didn’t matter anyway:
Furthermore, since Noonan v. City of Stillwater, 33 Minn. 198, 22 N. W. 444, 53 Am. R. 23, it has been settled that an ordinance or a charter provision cannot shift the responsibility of a city for the condition of its streets upon the abutting property or its owner or occupant.
— Abar v. Ramsey Motor Service, Inc., 195 Minn. 597, 599 (1935)
The general rule came in one sentence two pages later: “The duty of keeping the sidewalk in a reasonably safe condition for travel is placed on the city and not upon abutting owners or occupants.” Id. at 601. The court repeated it in 1950 and again in 1955, when it put the snow rule as plainly as it’s ever been put. Abutting owners and occupants “are not liable to pedestrians for injuries caused by stumbling or slipping on sidewalks which have become slippery and dangerous from natural, (as distinguished from artificial) accumulations of ice and snow.” Graalum v. Radisson Ramp, Inc., 245 Minn. 54, 59 (1955); see Bentson v. Berde’s Food Center, Inc., 231 Minn. 451, 455 (1950).
Knowing about the hazard doesn’t change that by itself. In Little Falls in 1950, a woman tripped on a ridge in the sidewalk that the roots of the homeowners’ tree had pushed up, and the owner admitted he’d watched that section rising for about two years. Sand v. City of Little Falls, 237 Minn. 233, 233–34 (1952). The Supreme Court reversed the verdict against the owners anyway, because “it was still the duty of the city to keep the sidewalk in a reasonably safe condition.” Id. at 234. Growing roots, the court said, were “a natural occurrence, as contrasted with overt acts on the part of the landowners.” Id. at 239.
The Court of Appeals still says it the same way. “Abutting property owners are liable for a sidewalk hazard only when it is caused at least partially by conditions they have created.” Olson v. City of St. James, 380 N.W.2d 555, 560 (Minn. Ct. App. 1986). In 1990 the same court applied the rule to a woman who fell on wet leaves on city property next to a Richfield building, and affirmed a directed verdict for the building’s owner. Strong v. Richfield State Agency, Inc., 460 N.W.2d 106, 108–09 (Minn. Ct. App. 1990).
I looked for a later Minnesota appellate decision that moves this line. I searched CourtListener’s Minnesota opinions from 1991 forward in four phrasings, by the case names and by the doctrinal words, and the Caselaw Access Project for the older reporters, and found none.
So what does the shoveling ordinance actually do to you?
It sends you a bill. Sometimes it puts that bill on your property taxes.
Minneapolis gives the owner of a single-family home or duplex 24 hours after it stops snowing to clear the public sidewalk, and every other property “4 daytime hours (8 a.m. to 5 p.m.)”. The city’s own page cites Minneapolis Ordinance 445.20 for the rule, and the quotes here are from that page, not the code. The city says it starts inspecting “24 hours after each snowfall.” If the walk still isn’t clear at follow-up, “Crews will remove the snow and ice and bill you”, and if you don’t pay, “We’ll add the fee amount to your property taxes.”
The same page adds a rule people miss. “You’re responsible for the sidewalk throughout the winter, not just when it snows.” Meltwater that runs onto your walk from a neighbor’s and refreezes is, in the city’s words, “your responsibility to clear or sand”. And: “It’s against the law to shovel snow into streets or alleys.”
St. Paul runs the same clock. The city’s page says its ordinance “requires owners to remove snow and ice from sidewalks within 24 hours”, and points to Chapters 113 and 114 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code. After a complaint, the Department of Safety and Inspections sends the owner a letter, an inspector checks the walk “usually 48 hours after sending the letter”, and if it’s still not clear “the City may send a crew to clear the sidewalk at the property owner’s expense.”
The Legislature built the collection side. A city’s governing body “may provide for the collection of unpaid special charges as a special assessment against the property benefited” for the cost of “snow, ice, or rubbish removal from sidewalks”. Minn. Stat. § 429.101, subd. 1(a)(1). The council may also put “primary responsibility upon the property owner or occupant to do the work personally” upon notice before the work is done. Id., subd. 1(b). An assessment can be payable in a single installment or in up to ten annual installments. Id., subd. 2.
That statute is a tax-collection tool, and it looks exactly like what Noonan said a sidewalk ordinance is: a duty owed to the city and enforced against the property. That’s why the bill is the risk. The bill is the whole design.
Doesn’t shoveling make it your responsibility?
No, and the Supreme Court went out of its way to say so.
People worry that clearing the walk once makes them responsible for it forever, so the safe move is to leave it alone. Minnesota rejected that in 1935. In Abar, the plaintiff’s theory was that the business had chipped at the ice, quit halfway, and left hummocks behind. The court found the proof “so tenuous that no verdict should be allowed to rest thereon”, 195 Minn. at 602, and then added this:
Occupants and owners of property abutting city streets often do clean or attempt to clean the sidewalk in front thereof. Their worthy efforts should not be discouraged by holding them liable where no liability otherwise exists simply because they endeavor to free the sidewalk of snow and ice.
— Abar, 195 Minn. at 603
In 1950 the court summarized Abar in one line: an owner who “has shoveled snow from his walk” does not “thereby assume liability for ice forming thereon from natural causes”. Bentson, 231 Minn. at 455. In 1990 the Court of Appeals said an owner’s “occasional removal of snow or leaves” didn’t create liability for hazards from natural causes. Strong, 460 N.W.2d at 109.
Abar didn’t say a shoveling job can never be the problem. It said the proof that the defendant’s half-finished ice-chipping created the ridges was too thin. If your own work leaves something on the walk that wasn’t nature’s doing, you’re closer to the next section than to this one.
So shovel. The ordinance requires it, the city will bill you if you don’t, and the law doesn’t punish you for trying.
Where homeowners actually get sued: ice they made
The same cases that protect you from natural snow carve out ice you caused. In Graalum’s words, if an abutting owner “maintains or uses his property in a manner whereby dangerous ice is caused to form on the adjacent sidewalk as a result of artificial, as distinguished from natural, causes, he is liable for injuries proximately caused to a pedestrian who slips and falls on such ice.” 245 Minn. at 60. Abar listed the usual suspects: an owner who “causes water to be diverted thereon which forms dangerous ice or drops ‘clumps’ of ice or deposits other obstructions thereon, he may be liable for injuries caused thereby.” 195 Minn. at 602.
The downspout case is a homeowner’s case, and it’s from Minneapolis. In January 1923 a woman slipped on a five- or six-inch mound of ice on the Thirty-fifth Street sidewalk beside a house on the corner of Longfellow Avenue. A drain pipe ran from the house down to the walk. The owner testified that it connected to the roof spout, that it was “plugged up and frozen up and cracked”, and that when it got full of ice it “busted”. He’d never repaired it. A police officer who walked past almost every day for six years said the walk “was worst at the drain pipe,” and that fresh snow that afternoon meant “you couldn’t see the ice”. The jury awarded $1,125 and the Supreme Court affirmed. Johnson v. Elmborg, 165 Minn. 67, 68–70 (1925).
The roof case is older and blunter. The Pence Opera House on Hennepin Avenue had a steep hipped roof that, every thaw, slid snow and ice off the cornice and onto the sidewalk. A man walking past was hit on the head. The owner argued he’d kept the roof as clear as he could. The Supreme Court said that wasn’t the question. Maintaining a roof shaped so its snow and ice would naturally fall into the street “is a nuisance, and constitutes negligence per se, for which the owner will be liable to any one injured thereby while lawfully passing along the sidewalk.” Hannem v. Pence, 40 Minn. 127, 130 (1889). And: “He was bound at his peril to keep the ice and snow that collect on his own roof within his own limits”. Id.
Two cautions run the other way. Proof matters. In Bentson the jury came back against the store alone, not the building’s owner. 231 Minn. at 452. To hold the store, the ice had to have come from one of three places: a sack of crushed ice left on the walk before dawn, a leaking meat-and-fish display window, or steam pipes under the walk that kept water dripping from the cornice from draining off. The court found the evidence insufficient on all three and reversed. Id. at 456–57. And in Olson a drain from the owners’ building “could direct water toward the hazardous area,” but there was “no evidence that any such flow of water contributed to the hazard”. 380 N.W.2d at 560. A downspout near the ice isn’t a case. A downspout that made the ice is.
There’s one more route, and it’s mostly for businesses. An owner who makes an “extraordinary use of a sidewalk for his own convenience” owes the public due care for that stretch. Graalum, 245 Minn. at 60. In Graalum it was a downtown Minneapolis parking ramp whose driveway crossed the whole width of a Seventh Street sidewalk and took 570 entering cars between 8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. on the day of the fall. Id. at 55, 61. Your driveway isn’t that. The court said the liability “arises not from the fact that the defendant is the owner or occupant of the property abutting on the sidewalk, but from the fact that he has, wilfully or negligently, been instrumental in causing the hazardous condition”. Id.
And all of this is about the public sidewalk. Your own driveway and the private walk to your front door are your land, and a different rule applies there. I covered that duty, and the 1972 case that rewrote it, at /news/minnesota-premises-liability-snow-and-ice/.
Then the city pays? Usually not that either.
This is the part that surprises the families. The homeowner usually owes no duty to the pedestrian, and the city that does is usually immune.
Minnesota’s municipal tort statute excludes from city liability “[a]ny claim based on snow or ice conditions on any highway or public sidewalk that does not abut a publicly owned building or publicly owned parking lot, except when the condition is affirmatively caused by the negligent acts of the municipality.” Minn. Stat. § 466.03, subd. 4(a). The sidewalk in front of a house doesn’t abut a publicly owned building. The Court of Appeals borrowed a New Jersey line for the rule: “when weather is the true culprit, the government is immune.” Koen v. Tschida, 493 N.W.2d 126, 128 (Minn. Ct. App. 1992), review denied (Minn. Jan. 28, 1993). And the exception takes an act, not a failure to act: the statute “requires the condition to have been caused by an act, not an omission,” id. (quoting an earlier decision), so a city that simply didn’t salt hasn’t lost its immunity.
So for a natural accumulation on a residential walk, the pedestrian may have no one to sue. The courts and the Legislature built it that way.
Where there may be a claim against a city, there’s a clock most people never hear about. Section 466.05 requires notice to the governing body “within 180 days after the alleged loss or injury is discovered”. Minn. Stat. § 466.05, subd. 1. The statute even counts “[a]ctual notice of sufficient facts” to put the city or its insurer on notice of a possible claim. Id. Put yours in writing anyway; arguing about actual notice is a fight you don’t want. I walked through that notice, the sidewalk immunity, and how the two fit together at /news/minnesota-injury-claim-against-a-city/, and through the rest of the immunity list at /news/minnesota-municipal-immunity-exceptions/.
What I’d do, on either side of the fall
If it’s your sidewalk:
- Clear it inside the city’s window. In Minneapolis that’s 24 hours for a house or duplex. That’s the rule with teeth for you, and the teeth are a bill.
- Go outside during the next thaw and watch where the water goes. If a downspout, a gutter seam, or a roof edge puts water on the public walk, fix it or extend it. That’s the fact pattern Minnesota has been holding owners liable on since 1925.
- Pile snow on your own yard or boulevard, never back onto the walk or into the street.
- Read the liability section of your homeowner’s policy before you need it. Most homeowner’s policies include personal liability coverage, and a claim from a fall in front of your house is the kind of thing that coverage exists to defend. Your policy’s own words control.
If you or your kid fell:
- Photograph the ice that day, and photograph what’s above and beside it. The downspout is the case.
- Write down the date and time and whether it was still snowing. Natural versus artificial is decided on facts like those.
- If a city may be involved, calendar the 180 days from the day you discovered the injury.
- If a claim does go forward, the walker’s own care is part of it. How Minnesota compares fault and adjusts a verdict is at /news/minnesota-comparative-fault-collateral-source/. Pedestrian claims against drivers are a different animal; that’s at /news/minnesota-bicycle-pedestrian-crash-claims/.
The city owns the snow. You own the gutters.
Madgett Law, LLC
Madgett Law, LLC represents people hurt in Minnesota, including pedestrian injuries and falls caused by a property owner’s failure to keep conditions safe. Whether a fall on a public walk was nature’s doing or somebody’s downspout, and whether a city is in the picture with its 180-day notice, can decide whether there’s a claim at all. Read about our personal injury practice, then send us a message.
Sources: Minn. Stat. § 429.101, subd. 1(a)(1) (special assessment for unpaid charges for snow and ice removal from sidewalks), subd. 1(b) (primary responsibility on owner or occupant upon notice), subd. 2 (single installment or up to ten annual installments); Minn. Stat. § 466.03, subd. 4(a) (municipal immunity for snow or ice conditions on a public sidewalk not abutting a publicly owned building or parking lot, unless affirmatively caused by the municipality’s negligent acts); Minn. Stat. § 466.05, subd. 1 (notice within 180 days after the loss or injury is discovered; actual notice of sufficient facts complies); City of Minneapolis, “Sidewalk Snow Clearing Rules” (24 hours for single-family homes and duplexes; 4 daytime hours for other properties; Minneapolis Ordinance 445.20; inspection, crew removal, billing, and property-tax assessment); City of Saint Paul, “Sidewalk Snow Shoveling” (24 hours; Saint Paul Legislative Code chs. 113 and 114; inspection and clearing at the owner’s expense); Noonan v. City of Stillwater, 33 Minn. 198, 199, 205, 206–07 (1885) (sidewalk duty owed only to the city; Mitchell, J., concurring); Hannem v. Pence, 40 Minn. 127, 129–30 (1889) (roof that discharges snow and ice on the sidewalk is a nuisance and negligence per se); Johnson v. Elmborg, 165 Minn. 67, 68–70 (1925) (homeowner liable for ice formed by drain pipe emptying onto public walk); Abar v. Ramsey Motor Service, Inc., 195 Minn. 597, 599, 601–03 (1935) (ordinance cannot shift city’s duty to abutting owner; diverted water, clumps of ice, and obstructions; shoveling efforts not a basis for liability); Bentson v. Berde’s Food Center, Inc., 231 Minn. 451, 452, 455–57 (1950) (verdict against the store alone; city’s duty; shoveling does not assume liability for natural ice; artificial-cause liability; three theories against the store insufficient); Sand v. City of Little Falls, 237 Minn. 233, 233–34, 239 (1952) (owners not liable for sidewalk ridge raised by roots of their tree though they knew of it; city’s duty; natural occurrence); Graalum v. Radisson Ramp, Inc., 245 Minn. 54, 55, 59–61 (1955) (natural versus artificial accumulations; extraordinary use); Olson v. City of St. James, 380 N.W.2d 555, 560 (Minn. Ct. App. 1986) (abutting owner liable only for conditions it created at least in part); Strong v. Richfield State Agency, Inc., 460 N.W.2d 106, 108–09 (Minn. Ct. App. 1990) (no duty to maintain abutting municipal property; occasional removal of snow or leaves); Koen v. Tschida, 493 N.W.2d 126, 128 (Minn. Ct. App. 1992), review denied (Minn. Jan. 28, 1993) (snow-and-ice immunity; act, not omission). This article is general information about Minnesota law, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.