A Texas Jury Gave a Paralyzed Patient $10.25 Million in Noneconomic Damages. The Cap Cut It to $250,000. Minnesota Doesn't Cap a Private Doctor.

November 1, 2026 · David J.S. Madgett

A professor went into a San Antonio skilled nursing facility for a rash. He put on evidence that the nurses never told his doctors about a new symptom, and the MRI that finally came showed a tumor compressing his spinal cord. “His paralysis proved to be permanent.” The jury found the facility 55 percent responsible and awarded him $10,250,000 ($10.25 million) in noneconomic damages. The trial court reduced that to $250,000, “as required by the Texas Medical Liability Act”, and the Supreme Court of Texas affirmed. Regent Care of San Antonio, L.P. v. Detrick, No. 19-0117, slip op. at 1–3, 13 (Tex. May 8, 2020).

Most of a jury’s $10.25 million, gone by statute. And Texas law makes the judge tell the jurors not to even wonder whether a cap applies.

In Minnesota, that verdict against a private doctor or hospital stands or falls on the evidence. There’s no cap. There was one once, for four years, and it’s the part of this story almost nobody remembers.

This round of my Minnesota-vs-Texas series, which started on the paycheck at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-wage-garnishment-571-922/, is about the patient. Last week’s round was dog bites, at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-dog-bite-one-bite-rule-347-22/.

What does the Texas cap actually say?

It’s usually described as “$250,000”. It’s more than one number, and the structure matters.

The doctors’ side gets one cap, no matter how many doctors you sue:

In an action on a health care liability claim where final judgment is rendered against a physician or health care provider other than a health care institution, the limit of civil liability for noneconomic damages of the physician or health care provider other than a health care institution, inclusive of all persons and entities for which vicarious liability theories may apply, shall be limited to an amount not to exceed $250,000 for each claimant, regardless of the number of defendant physicians or health care providers other than a health care institution against whom the claim is asserted or the number of separate causes of action on which the claim is based.

— Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 74.301(a) (emphasis added)

Sue a surgeon, an anesthesiologist, and a radiologist, and the three of them share one $250,000 limit for your noneconomic damages.

The institutions get a separate cap. One hospital: “not to exceed $250,000 for each claimant.” § 74.301(b). More than one: up to $250,000 each, but “not to exceed $500,000 for each claimant” across all of them. § 74.301(c). Add the two sides together and, by my arithmetic, the most a single patient can collect in noneconomic damages from everyone combined is $750,000. That’s the ceiling for a person who sued every doctor and at least two hospitals and won against all of them.

And “noneconomic” covers nearly everything that isn’t a bill or a paycheck: “physical pain and suffering, mental or emotional pain or anguish, loss of consortium, disfigurement, physical impairment, loss of companionship and society, inconvenience, loss of enjoyment of life, injury to reputation, and all other nonpecuniary losses of any kind other than exemplary damages.” Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.001(12); see § 74.001(a)(20).

Then the part I find hardest to defend. In every jury-tried health care claim, the court must instruct the jurors: “Do not consider, discuss, nor speculate whether or not liability, if any, on the part of any party is or is not subject to any limit under applicable law.” § 74.303(e)(1). So a Texas jury can sit through a paralysis case, return a number it believes is just, and have a statute cut it to $250,000 after the jurors have gone home. They’re instructed not to even wonder about that.

Medical bills and lost wages aren’t capped by § 74.301, which is why the Detrick judgment still came to $3,399,371. Slip op. at 3. The economic damages carried it. For a patient who doesn’t earn a paycheck, a retiree, a child, a stay-at-home parent, the economic damages are thin, and $250,000 is most of the case.

Texas had to amend its constitution to do this

Texas tried this before, in the old Medical Liability Act, article 4590i, and the Supreme Court of Texas threw it out.

In 1988 the court took a certified question from the Fifth Circuit about a fourteen-month-old paralyzed by a penicillin shot injected into an artery at an Army hospital near El Paso. The trial court had awarded him $1,500,000 for pain and suffering. Lucas v. United States, 757 S.W.2d 687, 688 (Tex. 1988). The old statute capped liability at “an amount not to exceed $500,000”. Id. at 688–89 (quoting the statute). The court held the cap violated the open-courts guarantee in article I, section 13 of the Texas Constitution: “We hold that the restriction is unreasonable and arbitrary”. Id. at 690. And it said why: “In the context of persons catastrophically injured by medical negligence, we believe it is unreasonable and arbitrary to limit their recovery in a speculative experiment to determine whether liability insurance rates will decrease.” Id. at 691.

Two years later the court drew the line that saved part of the old law. Wrongful death is a statutory claim, and the open-courts clause protects common-law claims. “Had we faced a wrongful death claim in Lucas, we could not have reached the same conclusion, for the open courts provision does not apply to statutory claims.” Rose v. Doctors Hospital, 801 S.W.2d 841, 845 (Tex. 1990).

So in 2003 Texas did the thing most states don’t. It changed the constitution. Article III, section 66, added September 13, 2003, says:

Notwithstanding any other provision of this constitution, the legislature by statute may determine the limit of liability for all damages and losses, however characterized, other than economic damages, of a provider of medical or health care with respect to treatment, lack of treatment, or other claimed departure from an accepted standard of medical or health care or safety, however characterized, that is or is claimed to be a cause of, or that contributes or is claimed to contribute to, disease, injury, or death of a person.

— Tex. Const. art. III, § 66(b) (emphasis added)

“Notwithstanding any other provision of this constitution”. That’s the open-courts clause, answered in seven words. The section applies “to a law enacted by the 78th Legislature, Regular Session, 2003, and to all subsequent regular or special sessions of the legislature”, § 66(d), and the current § 74.301 carries the history note “Added by Acts 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 204”. The Legislature even wrote a backup. If § 74.301 is ever struck down “by a method other than through legislative means,” § 74.302 switches on the same three caps, for providers who carry minimum insurance. § 74.302(a), (d).

Belt, suspenders, and a constitutional amendment. Nobody can say Texas wasn’t sure.

And if the patient dies?

A different cap, and it’s bigger than it looks on paper.

In a wrongful death or survival action on a health care claim, the limit “for all damages, including exemplary damages, shall be limited to an amount not to exceed $500,000 for each claimant”. § 74.303(a). That $500,000 is in 1977 dollars. It moves with the consumer price index for urban wage earners and clerical workers (CPI-W) “between August 29, 1977, and the time at which damages subject to such limits are awarded by final judgment or settlement.” § 74.303(b). I didn’t find a Texas agency or court publication that states the current indexed figure, so I won’t guess at one. It’s a formula that runs from August 29, 1977, forty-nine years before this article. Medical, hospital, and custodial care are carved out. § 74.303(c).

Rose is why Texas could cap death cases even before it amended the constitution.

Does Minnesota cap malpractice damages?

No. And I went looking hard, because “no statute” is a negative and one search isn’t a search.

I pulled the full current text of chapter 549 (judgments and damages, through § 549.41), chapter 604 (comparative fault and related tort rules, through § 604.415), and chapter 573 (wrongful death and survival, through § 573.21), and read for any limit on damages. The words “noneconomic” and “intangible” appear nowhere in any of them. The “Limitation” headings in chapter 549 are about a state agency not paying costs and disbursements. I read § 145.682, the expert-affidavit statute; it’s a gate, not a cap. And I read the medical-malpractice limitations statute, § 541.076, which sets a four-year deadline and nothing else.

What I did find surprised me. Minnesota had a cap. In 1986 the Legislature enacted § 549.23, titled “INTANGIBLE LOSSES; LIMITATIONS”:

Subd. 2. [LIMITATION.] In civil actions, whether based on contract or tort, the amount of damages per person for intangible losses may not exceed $400,000. Subd. 3. [JURY NOT INFORMED OF LIMITATION.] The court may not inform the jury of the existence of the limitation in subdivision 2.

— 1986 Minn. Laws ch. 455, § 88 (approved March 25, 1986)

Minnesota went a step past Texas there: the court couldn’t even mention the cap. Texas only tells jurors not to think about one. But look at what Minnesota capped. “‘intangible loss’ means embarrassment, emotional distress, and loss of consortium. Intangible loss does not include pain, disability or disfigurement.” Id., subd. 1 (emphasis added). Even when Minnesota had a cap, pain, disability, and disfigurement stayed outside it. Texas caps all three.

It didn’t last. In 1990 the Legislature passed an act whose title says it plainly, “repealing the limit on intangible loss damages”, and section 23 reads: “Minnesota Statutes 1988, sections 549.23 and 549.24, are repealed.” 1990 Minn. Laws ch. 555, § 23. The governor signed it May 3, 1990, and the repeal took effect the next day for causes of action arising on or after that date. Id. § 24. The Revisor’s entry for § 549.23 today reads “MS 1988 [Repealed, 1990 c 555 s 23]”.

Four years. As far as the current statutes and those two session laws show, it’s the only general cap Minnesota has put on what a jury can award an injured person against a private doctor or hospital.

Government is the exception, and it’s a big one. When the defendant is a “municipality” under chapter 466, its liability “shall not exceed” $500,000 “to any claimant” and $1,500,000 “for any number of claims arising out of a single occurrence,” for claims arising on or after July 1, 2009, and the award can’t include punitive damages. Minn. Stat. § 466.04, subd. 1(a)(3), (7), (b). The state caps its own liability the same way: $500,000 “to any claimant” for claims arising on or after July 1, 2009, and the same $500,000 for a death. Minn. Stat. § 3.736, subd. 4(c). Neither one is a malpractice cap. They’re caps on suing government, and they apply to a pothole and a public clinic alike.

Then what keeps a Minnesota verdict in check?

Not a number. A set of gates and a judge.

The front-end gate. A Minnesota malpractice plaintiff who needs an expert to make out the case must serve an affidavit of expert review “with the summons and complaint”, and then an expert-disclosure affidavit “within 180 days after commencement of discovery”. Minn. Stat. § 145.682, subd. 2. I wrote about how those deadlines actually run at /news/minnesota-expert-affidavit-merits-gate/. Texas has the same idea, harder: an expert report “not later than the 120th day after the date each defendant’s original answer is filed”, and if it isn’t served, the court “shall” dismiss “with prejudice” and award the defendant “reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of court”. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 74.351(a), (b). So Texas has the gate and the cap. Minnesota has the gate.

The clock. Four years from accrual, “whether based on a contract or tort”. Minn. Stat. § 541.076(b). The traps in that four years are at /news/minnesota-medical-malpractice-deadlines/.

The judge. A Minnesota trial court can grant a new trial for “Excessive or insufficient damages, appearing to have been given under the influence of passion or prejudice”. Minn. R. Civ. P. 59.01(e). A judge looks at this verdict, on this record. A cap is a legislature deciding in advance, for every patient it’s never met.

The offsets. Collateral-source payments can come off a Minnesota verdict after trial, in a proceeding I covered at /news/minnesota-collateral-source-offset/. And a large future-damages award triggers a hearing on payment over time under § 549.25, which is a hearing and not a discount; that’s at /news/minnesota-future-damages-and-present-value/.

Where Minnesota gives ground

Death cases. Minnesota doesn’t cap them, but it measures them narrowly. The recovery in a wrongful death action is “the amount the jury deems fair and just for all damages suffered by the decedent resulting from the injury prior to the decedent’s death and the pecuniary loss resulting from the death”. Minn. Stat. § 573.02, subd. 1. “Pecuniary loss” is the statute’s phrase, not mine, and it’s a narrower word than Texas’s list of “nonpecuniary losses” that its cap reaches. And a malpractice death action has its own deadline: “within three years of the date of death, but in no event shall be commenced beyond the time set forth in section 541.076.” Id.

Who wins this round?

The patient’s round goes to Minnesota, and it isn’t close. A Minnesota jury that finds $10 million in suffering gets its verdict reviewed by a judge who heard the case. A Texas jury that finds $10 million is instructed not to think about the cap, and then the cap does the thinking.

The physician’s insurer’s round goes to Texas, and Texas won’t apologize for it. It changed its constitution, wrote a backup statute, and told the jury not to think about it.

Minnesota tried that in 1986, minus the part about pain. It took the Legislature four years to change its mind.

Madgett Law, LLC

Madgett Law, LLC represents injured people in Minnesota, and we don’t represent insurance companies. More on how we handle injury cases is on our personal injury page. If something went wrong in a hospital or a clinic and you’re trying to figure out whether it was malpractice, the four-year clock and the expert-affidavit requirement are both already running, so send us a message.

Sources: Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.001(4), (12) (economic and noneconomic damages defined); § 74.001(a)(6), (20) (adopting § 41.001 definitions); § 74.301(a)–(c) and history note (noneconomic damages limits; added 2003, 78th Leg., ch. 204); § 74.302(a), (d) (alternative limitation; financial-responsibility amounts); § 74.303(a)–(c), (e)(1) (wrongful death and survival limit; CPI-W adjustment from August 29, 1977; medical-care exclusion; jury instruction); § 74.351(a), (b) (expert report; dismissal with prejudice and fees); Tex. Const. art. III, § 66(b), (d) (added Sept. 13, 2003) (Texas Constitution and Statutes, Texas Legislative Council). Regent Care of San Antonio, L.P. v. Detrick, No. 19-0117, slip op. at 1–3, 13 (Tex. May 8, 2020) (opinion from the Supreme Court of Texas case docket; rehearing denied Oct. 2, 2020); Lucas v. United States, 757 S.W.2d 687, 688–91 (Tex. 1988) (former cap violated Tex. Const. art. I, § 13); Rose v. Doctors Hospital, 801 S.W.2d 841, 845 (Tex. 1990) (open-courts provision does not reach statutory wrongful death claims). Minn. Stat. § 145.682, subd. 2 (expert affidavits); § 541.076(b) (four-year limitation); § 549.25 (future damages; hearing); § 573.02, subd. 1 (wrongful death; measure of recovery; three-year limit for malpractice death actions); § 466.04, subd. 1(a)(3), (7), (b) (municipal liability limits); § 3.736, subd. 4(c) (state tort liability limit); Minn. Stat. chs. 549, 573, and 604, full text read for any damages limit; Revisor’s entry for § 549.23 (“MS 1988 [Repealed, 1990 c 555 s 23]”) (Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, 2026 Minnesota Statutes); 1986 Minn. Laws ch. 455, § 88 (former § 549.23, intangible losses limited to $400,000; jury not informed), § 89 (former § 549.24), and effective-date section (approved March 25, 1986); 1990 Minn. Laws ch. 555, title, § 23 (repealer), § 24 (effective date; signed May 3, 1990). Minn. R. Civ. P. 59.01(e) (new trial for excessive damages). This article is general information about Minnesota law, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.

Get new guides by email

Plain-English guides to Minnesota law, sent when a new one is written. No schedule, nothing for sale.

Used only to send these guides. Unsubscribe from any email. This is attorney advertising — subscribing does not create an attorney–client relationship.

← All news & articles