To Garnish Before Judgment, Texas Wants a Judge and a Bond. Minnesota Wants 45 Days.

October 31, 2026 · David J.S. Madgett

In Texas, a creditor that wants to freeze your bank account before it has a judgment has to file a lawsuit, swear out an affidavit, get a judge to sign an order, and post a bond the judge sets. Even then it can’t touch your paycheck.

In Minnesota, if you haven’t answered, a creditor can freeze your account or your wages 45 days after it serves you, with no judge, no court file, and no bond. It fills out the forms itself.

This is part of the series on whether Minnesota or Texas actually protects the person who owes. The series starts with wages at /news/minnesota-vs-texas-wage-garnishment-571-922/, where I quoted Minnesota’s 45-day clause and moved on. This piece is the machinery on both sides, because the machinery is where the difference lives.

Minnesota has three ways in, and only one has a judge behind it

Section 571.71 lets a creditor issue a garnishment summons “[a]s an ancillary proceeding to a civil action for the recovery of money” in three situations. One is after a money judgment. One is before judgment, if the court orders it under § 571.93. The third is the 45-day clause: 45 or more days after the summons and complaint were served, when a default judgment “could have, but has not, been entered” under Rule 55.01(a). Minn. Stat. § 571.71(1)–(3).

The judgment route is ordinary. The other two both work before any judgment, they sit a few lines apart, and the Legislature made one of them hard and the other one easy. That surprised me.

The court-order route is built like a fortress

A creditor that wants a judge to authorize garnishment before judgment starts with a filed lawsuit. The court may order it only “if a summons and complaint, or copies of these documents, are filed with the appropriate court,” and only on one of seven grounds. Minn. Stat. § 571.93, subd. 1. Most of them sound like accusations: the debtor has hidden or disposed of nonexempt property, or moved it out of the state, or is about to, “with intent to delay or defraud” creditors; has converted property into money to put it beyond reach; committed an intentional fraud giving rise to the claim; or been convicted of a felony for conduct giving rise to it. Id., subd. 1(1)–(5). The other two cover quasi in rem jurisdiction and a debtor who can’t be served because he lives and works in a restricted-access building. Id., subd. 1(6)–(7).

Then the creditor has to prove it. On a noticed motion, an order may issue “only if the creditor has demonstrated the probability of success on the merits” and shown a ground, and even then it may not issue if “the circumstances do not constitute a risk to collectibility of any judgment that may be entered”. Minn. Stat. § 571.932, subds. 1, 3. Before the order issues, the court “shall require the creditor to post a bond in the penal sum of at least $500,” conditioned on paying the debtor’s costs and “all damages caused by the garnishment” if the debtor wins or the order is vacated. Id., subd. 6(a). The no-notice version is reserved for “extraordinary circumstances”, needs specific findings, must be “narrowly drafted to minimize any harm to the debtor”, and carries actual damages, costs, and attorney’s fees against a creditor whose application was made in bad faith. Minn. Stat. § 571.931, subds. 1, 3, 5.

That’s Minnesota taking prejudgment seizure seriously. Chapter 570, the attachment statute, is built the same way, and I walked through it and compared the two side by side at /news/minnesota-attachment-prejudgment-remedy/. That piece’s headline calls attachment an accusation. It is. So is the court-order route to garnishment.

And Minnesota’s courts hold creditors to it. In 2003 a bank holding a Texas default judgment for $66,450, plus interest and $22,150 in attorney fees, filed that judgment in Hennepin County along with an ex parte application for prejudgment garnishment, and got the debtor’s Minnesota account frozen. Irwin Union Bank & Trust Co. v. Speedy Car Wash, Inc., 672 N.W.2d 375, 376 (Minn. Ct. App. 2003). The court of appeals reversed. A foreign-judgment creditor using §§ 571.93 and 571.931 “must give the Minnesota court jurisdiction by filing and subsequently serving a summons and complaint, thus starting a separate action in this state.” Id. at 377. “Filing a foreign judgment does not satisfy the statute.” Id. at 378.

So a creditor holding a Texas judgment can’t shortcut the court-order route by waving it at a Minnesota clerk. Hold that thought.

The 45-day route skips every one of those steps

Now set clause (2) next to all that. No grounds. No showing that you’re hiding anything. No probability of success. No bond. No order. No filed complaint, because § 571.71(2) says the creditor doesn’t need to file a thing. I covered the notices the creditor does have to send, and the remarkably blunt warning the Legislature wrote for them, in the hub piece; I won’t repeat it here.

The creditor writes its own number. The garnishment summons states “the amount of the claim that remains unpaid”, and the bank or employer holds up to 110 percent of it. Minn. Stat. §§ 571.72, subd. 2(1), (5); 571.73, subd. 1. No judge checks the number first.

The form says a court did something it didn’t. The statutory garnishment summons, which the creditor or its lawyer signs, opens its instructions to your bank or employer with this: “A court has ordered that you must serve a written statement to the creditor (or to the creditor’s lawyer).” Minn. Stat. § 571.74. That’s the Legislature’s own form. On the 45-day route there may not be a court file, let alone an order. It also has a blank for the “Court File Number”. Id.

Your wages can be reached, too. Minnesota requires an exemption notice in “every garnishment where the debtor is a natural person”, and when the target is earnings, that notice has to be served ten or more days before the first garnishment summons. Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 8; § 571.924, subd. 1. The 45-day route is no exception. Then the employer holds nonexempt earnings for the paydays that fall within the next 90 days. Minn. Stat. § 571.73, subd. 3(1).

The freeze lasts longer before judgment than after. This one I didn’t expect. If the garnishee was served before judgment and is holding your money, it’s discharged and returns the money 270 days after service, unless a timely motion keeps it on the hook. Served after judgment, it’s 180. Minn. Stat. § 571.79(c)–(d), (h). The money is held, not paid over, until the creditor serves a writ of execution, you authorize release to the creditor, the creditor authorizes release to you, a court orders it, or the law lets it go. Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 2(5). Still, nine months is a long time to go without part of your paycheck or your rent money.

Skip one $15 check and the whole thing is void. “A garnishee shall be paid a $15 fee by the creditor at the time of service of a garnishment summons”. Minn. Stat. § 571.76. And “Failure to pay the fee renders the garnishment void, and the garnishee shall take no action.” Id. The statutory summons tells you whether it was paid: “The Garnishee was paid $15.” Minn. Stat. § 571.74. Look for that line.

Who the 45-day route is actually for

Clause (2) has one real limit, and it’s hiding in the cross-reference. The default has to be one that “could have” been entered under Rule 55.01(a), and Rule 55.01(a) lets the court administrator enter judgment only when the claim “is upon a contract for the payment of money only,” or for state taxes. Minn. R. Civ. P. 55.01(a). Everything else has to go to a judge. Id. 55.01(b). I wrote about how narrow that box is at /news/minnesota-default-judgment-rule-55/.

The Eighth Circuit applied that limit in 2001. A couple had four checks totaling $50.25 bounce; the law firm collecting them sued, didn’t get an answer, mailed a Notice of Intent to Garnish, and then served a garnishment summons claiming $979.15. The bank froze the account. Picht v. Jon R. Hawks, Ltd., 236 F.3d 446, 447–48 (8th Cir. 2001). The court read clause (2) for what it is: “Thus, by its own terms, this procedure may be employed without prior entry, by a judge or otherwise, of a judgment against the debtor.” Id. at 449. But the bad-check penalty needed a judge to set it, so a clerk’s default wasn’t available, so the garnishment wasn’t authorized, and using it violated the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Id. at 451. I covered that case’s bad-check side at /news/minnesota-dishonored-check-civil-penalty-604-113/. It’s a federal court reading Minnesota law, not a Minnesota court, but it’s the most detailed reading of clause (2) I found.

Now apply the same logic to a debt buyer. Since 2013, a party seeking a default judgment “upon an assigned obligation arising out of any consumer debt” that was in default when assigned “shall apply to the court” and submit seven kinds of proof, including the contract with the original creditor (or other evidence of the account’s terms) and a complete chain of assignment. Minn. Stat. § 548.101(a). That’s the court track, not the clerk’s desk. On my reading, a debt buyer suing on a charged-off card can’t get a Rule 55.01(a) default, so it can’t use the 45-day route either; it needs a judgment or a § 571.93 order. I couldn’t find a Minnesota decision on the point; I searched CourtListener’s Minnesota state and federal opinions three ways. What § 548.101 requires is at /news/minnesota-debt-buyer-judgments-548-101/.

If that reading holds, the 45-day route belongs mostly to the original lender suing on its own account for a fixed balance. Which is to say, the bank that issued the card.

You got the Notice of Intent to Garnish. What can you do?

An answer is the cleanest way out. Clause (2) garnishment is effective only if the creditor “does not receive an Answer from the debtor within 25 days after service of the Notice of Intent to Garnish.” Minn. Stat. § 571.71(2). The statutory notice tells you “You have 20 days to do one of the following”. Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 11. Go by the 20. An answer the creditor receives in time keeps a clause (2) garnishment from taking effect.

Claim your exemptions. The forms come with the notices. Once a bank account is frozen, you have 14 days from the postmark on the bank’s mailing to return the exemption claim, with 60 days of bank statements to the creditor’s lawyer, though leaving out the form or the statements doesn’t waive the exemption. Minn. Stat. § 571.913. The creditor then has six business days to return any of your money it’s holding or object. Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 9(c).

Read how that objection gets made: by “filing the notice of objection and requesting a hearing” “in the district court that issued the judgment”. Id., subd. 9(c)(1). On the 45-day route, there isn’t one. The statute assumes a judgment the clause was written to skip.

Filing the case yourself is an option. It sounds backwards. Anything you want a judge to do, from deciding an exemption (“Upon motion of any party in interest, on notice, the court shall determine the validity of any claim of exemption and may make any order necessary to protect the rights of those interested”) to vacating a garnishment that wasn’t authorized, needs a court file. Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 9(b). Minnesota’s one-year filing rule, Minn. R. Civ. P. 5.04(a), says when an action must be filed; it doesn’t say the plaintiff has to be the one who files it. The cover-sheet rule speaks of “a party filing a civil case”. Minn. Gen. R. Prac. 104. And the fee statute charges a defendant $310 “when the first paper is filed for that party in said action”. Minn. Stat. § 357.021, subd. 2(1). If you can’t afford it, a court may authorize “the commencement or defense of any civil action” without fees on a proper affidavit. Minn. Stat. § 563.01, subd. 3(a). How a pocket-served case gets onto the docket, and what happens if nobody files it within a year, is at /news/minnesota-service-of-process-rule-4/.

Know what a wrong garnishment costs the creditor. A creditor that serves a garnishment summons before judgment “except when garnishment before entry of judgment is permitted under this chapter, is liable to the debtor named in the garnishment proceedings in the amount of $100, plus actual damages, plus reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.” Minn. Stat. § 571.90. Bad faith in violation of the chapter “renders the garnishment void” on top of the same liability. Id. If a court finds a creditor used an altered form that misleads you about your rights, you’re awarded actual damages, costs, fees, and up to $100. Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 7. A debt collector, as Picht shows, can also answer under federal law. And a collection firm can’t call it protected litigation conduct. The federal district court in Minnesota held that “Minnesota common law does not provide a litigation privilege that permits a debt collector to violate § 571.71 or § 571.72 with impunity.” Gallagher v. Gurstel, Staloch & Chargo, P.A., 645 F. Supp. 2d 795, 805 (D. Minn. 2009).

Texas won’t let a creditor skip the judge

Texas starts with a statute that lists when garnishment is available at all. Before judgment, unless an attachment has already issued, the creditor has to be a plaintiff who “sues for a debt” and swears that “the debt is just, due, and unpaid”, that “within the plaintiff’s knowledge, the defendant does not possess property in Texas subject to execution sufficient to satisfy the debt”, and that “the garnishment is not sought to injure the defendant or the garnishee”. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 63.001(1)–(2). No lawsuit, no garnishment.

Then the Supreme Court of Texas’s rules add the parts Minnesota’s 45-day route leaves out:

  • A judge, every time. “No writ shall issue before final judgment except upon written order of the court after a hearing, which may be ex parte.” Tex. R. Civ. P. 658. The application has to be supported by affidavits “made on personal knowledge”, with facts on information and belief allowed only “if the grounds of such belief are specifically stated.” Id.
  • Findings and a ceiling. The order must make “specific findings of facts” and “shall specify the maximum value of property or indebtedness that may be garnished and the amount of bond required of plaintiff.” Id. The creditor doesn’t write its own number. The judge does.
  • A bond for you. No writ issues before judgment until the creditor files “a bond payable to the defendant in the amount fixed by the court’s order,” conditioned on paying the damages and costs adjudged “for wrongfully suing out such writ of garnishment.” Tex. R. Civ. P. 658a. Rule 658 says the amount should “adequately compensate defendant”. The rule sets no minimum.
  • A docket. The garnishment is docketed as its own case, the creditor against the bank or other garnishee. Tex. R. Civ. P. 659. There’s a case number from day one.
  • Notice, after the fact. You’re served with the writ, the application, the affidavits, and the orders “as soon as practicable after service of the writ on the garnishee”, and the copy you get must tell you, in English and Spanish, “Your money or property has been frozen or seized” and where to find free legal help. Tex. R. Civ. P. 663a. Texas freezes first and tells you second. Minnesota’s 45-day route, to its credit, sends the Notice of Intent first.
  • A fast way out. You can replevy by posting your own bond. Tex. R. Civ. P. 664. Or you can file a sworn motion to dissolve. If it rests on exemptions and gives the information the Supreme Court’s claim form asks for, it runs on Rule 679b’s exemption procedure. On any other ground, it “must be determined within ten days after the motion is filed, unless extended for good cause shown”, stays further proceedings under the writ, and puts the burden back on the creditor: “The writ must be dissolved unless, at such hearing, the plaintiff proves the statutory grounds relied upon for the writ’s issuance”, though the court may modify the writ instead. Tex. R. Civ. P. 664a.

And through all of it, your paycheck is off the table. “Except as otherwise provided by state or federal law, current wages for personal service are not subject to garnishment.” Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 63.004. A Texas prejudgment writ can reach a bank account. It can’t reach a payroll office.

Texas isn’t strict everywhere, though. Its grounds are easy. A Minnesota creditor asking a judge for prejudgment garnishment has to show something like intent to hide or defraud, plus a likely win. A Texas creditor mostly has to swear it doesn’t know of enough Texas property to satisfy the debt, a bar plenty of ordinary debtors clear without having done anything wrong, and the hearing can be ex parte. On the grounds alone, Minnesota’s court-order route is tougher than Texas’s. But Minnesota hands its creditors a second route that needs no grounds at all, and Texas doesn’t have one.

The scorecard

Texas wins this round, and it isn’t close. Before judgment, a Texas creditor needs a pending lawsuit, a sworn application on personal knowledge, a signed order with findings, a judge-set ceiling, and a bond payable to you, and it still can’t garnish wages. A Minnesota creditor on a fixed-balance contract claim needs 45 days, a couple of notices, and your silence, and it can reach your wages and your bank account and hold them for as long as 270 days.

Minnesota built a fortress at the front door and left a side door open with a welcome mat. It wrote the court-order route so carefully that its court of appeals turned away a bank holding a Texas judgment, and then let a lender with a fixed-balance contract claim skip the court entirely.

Madgett Law, LLC

Madgett Law, LLC handles garnishment and exemption fights and defends Minnesotans sued on consumer and medical debt, including the suits that end in default judgments and garnishments. We also help people look at settlement and negotiated alternatives before a judgment narrows the options (more on that on our bankruptcy avoidance page), and at what Minnesota’s exemptions already protect (distressed asset protection). If you’ve been served with a summons and complaint, or a Notice of Intent to Garnish just showed up, don’t wait out the 20 days. Send us a message.

Sources: Minn. Stat. § 571.71(1)–(3) (garnishment as an ancillary proceeding; three instances; clause (2): 45 days after service, default could have been entered under Rule 55.01(a), Notice of Intent to Garnish and Exemption form, 25 days without an Answer, no filing required); § 571.72, subd. 2(1), (5) (summons states unpaid claim; garnishee retains up to 110 percent until execution, release, court order, or operation of law), subd. 7 (misleading forms; damages, costs, fees, up to $100), subd. 8 (exemption notice in every garnishment of a natural person; earnings notice ten days before first summons), subd. 9(b)–(c) (motion to determine exemption; creditor’s six business days; objection filed in the district court that issued the judgment), subd. 11 (Notice of Intent to Garnish form; 20 days); § 571.73, subds. 1, 3(1) (110 percent retention; earnings for paydays within 90 days); § 571.74 (statutory garnishment summons form; “A court has ordered”; $15 paid); § 571.76 ($15 garnishee fee paid by creditor; garnishment void if unpaid); § 571.79(c)–(d), (h) (discharge 270 days after a prejudgment summons, 180 days after a postjudgment summons; motion exception); § 571.90 (liability for unauthorized prejudgment garnishment and for bad faith; $100, actual damages, fees and costs); § 571.913 (14 days to claim exemption on bank funds; 60 days of statements; no waiver); § 571.924, subd. 1 (earnings exemption notice ten days before summons); § 571.93, subd. 1(1)–(7) (court-ordered prejudgment garnishment; filed summons and complaint; grounds, including a felony conviction for the act giving rise to the claim); § 571.931, subds. 1, 3, 5 (before notice and hearing; extraordinary circumstances; required findings; bad-faith damages); § 571.932, subds. 1, 3, 6(a) (after notice and hearing; probability of success; risk to collectibility; bond of at least $500); § 548.101(a) (assigned consumer debt defaults; application to the court; required proof); § 357.021, subd. 2(1) ($310 fee on a defendant’s first paper); § 563.01, subd. 3(a) (court fee waiver). Minn. R. Civ. P. 5.04(a) (one-year filing deadline); Minn. R. Civ. P. 55.01(a)–(b) (administrator default judgment on a contract for the payment of money only; all other cases to the court). Minn. Gen. R. Prac. 104 (party filing a civil case). Irwin Union Bank & Trust Co. v. Speedy Car Wash, Inc., 672 N.W.2d 375, 376–78 (Minn. Ct. App. 2003). Picht v. Jon R. Hawks, Ltd., 236 F.3d 446, 447–51 (8th Cir. 2001). Gallagher v. Gurstel, Staloch & Chargo, P.A., 645 F. Supp. 2d 795, 805 (D. Minn. 2009). Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 63.001(1)–(2) (garnishment grounds; prejudgment affidavit); § 63.004 (current wages not subject to garnishment) (Texas Constitution and Statutes, Texas Legislative Council). Tex. R. Civ. P. 658 (application; affidavits on personal knowledge or stated grounds of belief; written order after hearing, which may be ex parte; findings; maximum value; bond), 658a (bond payable to the defendant), 659 (case docketed), 663a (service on defendant; required notice), 664 (replevy), 664a (dissolution or modification; exemption-based motions follow Rule 679b; ten days for motions on other grounds; stay; plaintiff’s burden; modification), 679b (exemption procedure) (Supreme Court of Texas, Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, txcourts.gov, last amended October 1, 2026). This article is general information about Minnesota law, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship, and no outcome is promised or implied.

Get new guides by email

Plain-English guides to Minnesota law, sent when a new one is written. No schedule, nothing for sale.

Used only to send these guides. Unsubscribe from any email. This is attorney advertising — subscribing does not create an attorney–client relationship.

← All news & articles